If this goes nowhere, I apologize. I'm going to type it, hit "publish" and that's that. Your job, gentle reader, is to correct me if and where I go astray. Thanks.As alluded to
here, I've had a lot of time lately to think about church. It's been an interesting past year and a half to say the least—and that for a whole host of reasons. In a broad sense I've been trying to understand the "little c" church and the contending going on even as we speak between a number of vastly different viewpoints (more on that later). On a more personal level I've been trying to figure out the "big C" church, Christianity, the world and my place in it.
The biggest issue that I can see, and the one that seems to be the most universal, is what I might call an unhealthy view of man and a very small view of God. We can see it I think quite clearly in the world of the Emergent church with it's "dreams of Jesus" to be fulfilled and it's high, and almost reverent love of the earth and the things of man more than God (From what I can understand about the Emergent "conversation" it's basically an organization that believes it's okay for you to sleep with your girlfriend as long as you eat organic carrots.) So for those of us with a reasonably high view of Scripture it is not difficult to see the inherent problem in such a viewpoint.
Where I think things can get hazy are in our very own, sacred, safe Evangelical Mainline Protestant havens. Even as we denounce relativism, "Social Gospel" and other "liberal" practices, I wonder if we aren't perpetuating something that, if not quite as deadly, is far more insidious. I wonder if in our efforts to "guard the truth" we haven't shut the door in the face of those genuinely seeking to understand and apply God's word. I wonder if in our efforts to show "great leadership" we haven't co-opted the patterns of the world by turning the church into nothing more than a corporation with CEOs and Mission Statements; a culture where "If you don't like it then sell your stock and here's the door."
This I think is the real problem and it's a problem that knows no boundary, no affiliation and no denomination. We can see it just as easily in traditional church governing systems as we can in legalistic and high-authority systems.
This to me is the biggest issue the "big C" church needs to confront: Is God sovereign over all or is he not? Does God speak through the whole body of Christ or does he not? Does each member of Christ's body have a connection to the head or not? Is the head God or a man or a system devised by man?
Certainly these questions need to be answered correctly but beyond that they need to be
applied to our systems, our structures and—most importantly—our practices. Belief without action is nothing. We might sing that He is "Lord of Lords" but do we really believe that? Or do we take the view that our church is Lord, our system is Lord, and our leaders are Lords?
This isn't really anything new. All through church history we see a pattern of man elevating himself and then being quickly humbled by a Sovereign God. Unfortunately Christians are like everyone else in that they learn almost nothing from history (or for that matter things currently happening in front of their noses).
I think we also can't go too far the other way and simplistically say "God doesn't work through man" because that is simply not the case. After all it took God's stirring on the heart of Luther to enact change in the world by exposing the perverted form of Christianity that was Roman Catholicism. But did ultimate change come from one man dictating and others following? Or was it a swell, an urging by the Holy Spirit working on the hearts of thousands of men and women from various backgrounds to restore the idea of man's direct connection with God through the cross?