For what it's worth (probably very little) here are my top 5 movies of 2004—and my pick for worst movie of the year just to round things out.
5. "Napoleon Dynamite"
This is a very very strange movie—I'll start off by saying that. It earns no points for it's plot or it's performances but earns my #5 spot soley on it's goodwill and charm. First time director Jared Hess has created a veritable tour de force of geekdom, a celebration of the strange and offbeat. Many who see this film will find it utterly inane and stupid, and this is a perfectly valid reaction. What makes it work for me is it's singularly focused display of subtle humor. In the comedy genre we are so used to seeing sex jokes, fart jokes, people eating poop and guys getting hit in the crotch. Here is a movie without an iota of sexually suggestive nonsense, or gross-out gags. I gather that in this day and age people just can't accept subtle humor and as such this flick will probably go over their heads. But if you're like me (and hopefully you aren't), you appreciate it when someone attempts to do something original and fresh in comedy.
4. "Garden State"
This is the best movie on the post-modern generation you are ever going to see. Zach Braff from "Scrubs" wrote, directed and stars in this drama/comedy, or "dramedy" if you will. Braff plays Andrew Largeman, an overly medicated and struggling actor who returns to his home state of New Jersey for his mother's funeral. He is almost completely detached from and uneffected by his mother's passing and instead finds himself encoutering old and new friends, each pulling him in a different direction. This movie has a lot of little jokes and funny situations (again it's subtle humor) but I was also impressed by the dramatic moments. The scene at the party after Andrew takes XTC is the best anti-drug commercial I have ever seen. When you are already taking Zoloft, Paxil and lithium what's another drug anyway?
Natalie Portman delivers here as well. Her character is not without her own set of problems but she functions beautifully as Andrew's emotional conscience. While we don't actually get to see Braff's character resolve his issues we do get the sense at the end of the movie he is on the right track. It's not a perfect movie as there is a lot of cussing and a totally unnecessary, albeit brief scene 3/4 of the way through (skip chapter 17). But if you're looking for a great take on the mentality of the 20-somethings in this generation, you'll dig this movie.
3. "The Village"
M.Night Shaymalan is 3 for 4 in my book. While most think it's his crowning achivement I absolutely hated "The Sixth Sense". I thought it was bleak, contrived and way too dark. "Unbreakable" I liked and "Signs" is one of my favorite movies of all time. Now here is "The Village" and we somehow think we know how this M.Night Shaymalamadingdong makes his movies—scary, slow moving and with a "twist" at the end. If all you're looking for is great "twist" you'll have to look elsewhere. While the "twist" is interesting (in a "Twilight Zone" sort of way) it is not enough to make the picture work. I was more intrigued by the suspense Night can pull out of thin air and his masterful control of pacing, plot and camera movement. I also appriciate the sympathy he creates for his characters, including the "bad guys" and supporting characters. Some see this movie as a morality play on the power of fear and how those in charge use fear to control us (a stab at the current administration no doubt). I see it quite differently. This is a movie about the dangers of isolation, and how creating distance from the "world's problems" doesn't make the problems go away.
2. "The Incredibles"
Pixar continues to amaze me. Their worst movie ("A Bug's Life") it's still 4x better than 95% of what Hollywood barfs at us every year. Although Disney tends to get a lot of the credit for these CG projects, Pixar actually does the hard work. And not just the techinical aspects but the conception, writing, casting and animation are all done under Pixar's roof. "Toy Story 2" ruled, but this may be the best thing they've ever produced. I'm not a huge fan of the "super-hero" genre, so I'm not the best to comment, but I think this is the best super-hero movie ever made. It's so much more than just a silly animated movie. The film's director Brad Bird gives us comedy, action, adventure, suspense and drama all in one energetic package. "The Incredibles" is PG so Pixar didn't need to shy away from too much violence or peril and make the film wimpy. Animation is such a great art form and hopefully this a sign of things to come for those of us who'd like to see more from animation than just singing woodland creatures.
1. "The Passion of the Christ"
It almost seems to obvious to put his at #1. Then again, it
is the greatest movie ever made. Upon seeing it I remarked: "Hollywood should just stop making movies now. There's no point anymore. They should all play badminton or work at Target instead." It's easy to focus on the drama and emotion this film generates, which I appreciate. But what grabs me more is the technical precision seen in this movie. The cinematography, set design, costuming, and acting are all first-rate. The editing technique and skill is unreal, and I found it to be the most moving juxtaposition of images I'd ever seen. The humanity of Christ is also very striking. He wasn't some Herculean demi-god, but a real flesh and blood man, and despite all the chaos going on Mel Gibson never once loses sight of that fact. Roger Ebert gave it a favorable review, but also called it "the most violent film I've ever seen." He's full of crap. While certainly graphic, the violence is utterly and brutally real, and dosen't ever approach the gratuitousness of say, one of the "Friday the 13th" movies. The movie makes it's point abundantly clear: Christ's death was real, and every man and woman has to make a decision about it. There is no middle ground. It'll be lucky to get even one nomination by the Academy, much less "Best Picture", but make no mistake-it's both the greatest movie of 2004 and the best movie ever made.
Worst movie of the year: "Saved!"
Ugh. Where to start on this one. Being the fan of
"Mystery Science Theater 3000" that I am, I've seen alot of terrible, terrible movies. While not the worst movie ever made, this is certainly a terrible, terrible movie. I have no problem with satire, even satire pointed at Christianity. But this movie is so graceless and hackneyed in it's handling of the subject it will make you gag. Can we get another message out of Hollywood other than "I'm okay, you're okay"? Probably not. I didn't need the gay kid to convert at the end or anything, but could we at least show that Christian's can coexist with "sinners" without acting like buttholes or supplanting their beliefs with moral relativism? Read my
comments on IMDB for more.
Note: If you liked this movie, there is something very wrong with you.